How to get your Thanksgiving order

We're offering two ways to get your Thanksgiving order:

  • Store pickup: Wednesday, November 25, 10:00am – 6:00pm, at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave.

  • Home delivery: Wednesday, November 25, 10:00am – 4:00pm, for a $45 flat fee. Your driver will text you an ETA when they're on the way, so please have someone home to receive it. Delivery covers most addresses within about 40 minutes of the store, and checkout will offer it if yours is in range.

About the pickup location question at checkout: you'll still see the pickup spots we use for our weekly meals. Thanksgiving orders can only be picked up at our Wauwatosa store, so whichever location you choose there, your order will be waiting for you at the store. Thank you for understanding, and we can't wait to be part of your Thanksgiving!

⬇️⬇️Scroll down to see this years menu!⬇️⬇️

Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving

Filters

Quick View
BAKED MAC & CHEESE

Baked macaroni and cheese with sharp cheddar, Colby, and Monterey Jack.

Feeds 8-10 people


SE Dietary Categories: V | NF | FF


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$40.00
Quick View
BRUSSELS SPROUTS SALAD

Shaved Brussels sprouts, toasted almonds, Parmesan cheese, and dried cranberries, with lemon herb vinaigrette on the side.

Feeds 8-10 people


SE Dietary Categories: GF | V


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$40.00
Quick View
BUTTERNUT SQUASH CASSEROLE

Butternut squash and sweet potato casserole with kale, Parmesan cheese, spinach artichoke spread, sautéed red onion, roasted almonds, sea salt, herbs, and cracked black pepper.

Feeds 8-10 people


SE Dietary Categories: GF | V


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$45.00
Quick View
COLLARD GREEN ARTICHOKE DIP

Collard green and artichoke dip with Southern love, served with crusty sourdough.

Feeds 8-10 people


SE Dietary Categories: V | NF


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$45.00
Quick View
CRANBERRY LOAF

A festive cranberry loaf bursting with tangy cranberries and warm spices. Perfect for Thanksgiving.

SE Dietary Categories: V | NF | FF


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$20.00
Quick View
GARLIC & HERB WHIPPED POTATOES

Garlic and herb whipped organic Yukon gold potatoes with olive oil, grass-fed butter, sour cream, sea salt, and cracked black pepper.

Feeds 8-10 people


SE Dietary Categories: GF | V | NF | EF


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$35.00
Quick View
GREEN BEAN CASSEROLE

Green bean casserole with sautéed mushrooms, onions, homemade béchamel sauce (never canned), fresh herbs, and crispy onion strings.

Feeds 8-10 people


SE Dietary Categories: V | NF


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$40.00
Quick View
PEAR & APPLE CRISP

Pear and apple crisp with a candied pecan crumble, oats, grass-fed butter, and sea salt caramel sauce.

Feeds 8-10 people


SE Dietary Categories: V


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$45.00
Quick View
QUINOA STUFFED SQUASH

Quinoa-stuffed acorn squash with candied pecans, pumpkin seeds, dried cranberries, fresh herbs, and maple tahini vinaigrette.

Feeds 8-10 people


SE Dietary Categories: GF | VG | DF


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$50.00
Quick View
ROASTED VEGETABLE TART

Roasted carrots, parsnips, rutabagas, and leeks over herb cream cheese in a buttery crust.

Feeds 8-10 people


SE Dietary Categories: V | NF


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$45.00
Quick View
SMOKED TURKEY & GRAVY

Smoked turkey served with rich gravy.

Serves 10


SE Dietary Categories: HP | NF


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$70.00
Quick View
SMOKED TURKEY CORNBREAD DRESSING

Cornbread dressing with smoked turkey, celery, onion, sage, and sweet bell peppers.

Feeds 8-10 people


SE Dietary Categories: NF | FF


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$45.00
Quick View
SOURDOUGH STUFFING

Sourdough stuffing with chicken sausage, celery, onion, grass-fed butter, herbs, sea salt, and cracked black pepper.

Feeds 8-10 people


SE Dietary Categories: NF


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$45.00
Quick View
THANKSGIVING PUMPKIN COOKIES

Soft, cake-like pumpkin cookies with pumpkin pie spices, slathered with brown butter frosting. A perfect Thanksgiving treat!

12 cookies per order


SE Dietary Categories: V | NF | FF


Pickup or delivery: Pick up at our Wauwatosa store, 7227 W North Ave, or choose $45 home delivery at checkout. Please note: all Thanksgiving pickups are at our Wauwatosa store, even if you choose one of our weekly pickup spots at checkout.

$25.00

No results found

No results match your search. Try removing a few filters.